| Platinum | Chapman's Ice Cream |
| Platinum | Pumpkin Patch |
| Platinum | Snow's Ice Cream Shop |
| Gold | Bates Landing Roadside Market |
| Gold | Octopus Ice Cream |
| Gold | The Cool Zone |
| Silver | Bella's Traditional Ice Cream |
| Bronze | Sussex Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Melt Down |