| Platinum | Britt's Pub and Eatery |
| Platinum | Pür & Simple |
| Gold | Island Girls Diner |
| Silver | K's East Side Cafe |
| Bronze | Big Stop Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Britt's Rockwood |
| Top Pick | Cora's Breakfast & Lunch |
| Top Pick | Lily's |
| Top Pick | Sandwich Junkies |
| Top Pick | Sunset Grill |