| Platinum | Italian by Night |
| Gold | East Side Mario's Saint John |
| Silver | Vito's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Romano's Pizza & Spaghetti House |
| Top Pick | Big Daddy's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Delizioso Bistro & Sweets |
| Top Pick | Mother Nature's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sisters Italian Foods |
| Top Pick | Vivaldi's |