| Platinum | Big D's Poutine |
| Gold | Spinneys Seafood Market |
| Silver | Grannan's Seafood |
| Bronze | Lily's |
| Top Pick | Billy’s Seafood Company |
| Top Pick | Birch Grove Restaurant & Take-Out |
| Top Pick | Bob's Corner Take-Out |
| Top Pick | Clam Digger |
| Top Pick | North Market |
| Top Pick | Steamers Lobster Co. |