| Platinum | Island Girls Diner |
| Gold | Mabel Kitchen |
| Silver | Pumpkin Patch |
| Bronze | Bella's Traditional Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | BeaverTails |
| Top Pick | Cotton Candies Life Is Sweet |
| Top Pick | Starbucks |
| Top Pick | Sweet Vanilla |
| Top Pick | Sweetums Sweet Treats |
| Top Pick | The Sugar Spider |