| Platinum | Romano's Pizza & Spaghetti House |
| Gold | Vito's Restaurant |
| Silver | Pizza Delight |
| Silver | Top's Pizza & Restaurant |
| Bronze | Pomodori Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Casey's Pizza & Chicken Shack |
| Top Pick | Italian by Night |
| Top Pick | Julius Pizza |
| Top Pick | Little Caesars |
| Top Pick | Salvatore |
